Crystal Clear: The evolution of the eye, part 2

“I am inclined to believe that in nearly the same way as two men have sometimes independently hit on the very same invention, so natural selection, working for the good of each being and taking advantage of analogous variations, has sometimes modified in very nearly the same manner two parts in two organic beings, which owe but little of their structure in common to inheritance from the same ancestor.”

Charles Darwin, The Origin of Species

To put Darwin’s statement in other words, it looks very much as if the processes of evolution have hit upon the same solution multiple times. We’ve had posts on ‘convergent evolution’ on Science and Belief in the past, so I will leave you to read A Dentist’s Guide to the Map of Life, or Inevitable Humans? if you want a little more explanation of this phenomenon. In this article I want to concentrate on the makeup of eye.

5228946002_22298b96c4_o (1).jpg
Italy-1453-Murano Glass by Dennis Jarivs. Flickr. (CC BY-SA 2.0)

The furnaces for making glass are heated up to a roasting 1000oC or more. So how is it that the optical machinery of the eye can be made at 37oC? A living lens is made when cells fill up with a material that makes it transparent, squeezing out everything else – including the DNA. But what is it that makes the lens so clear, strong, and long lasting?

Crystallins are small proteins that come together to form not crystals (despite the name) but a smooth and tightly packed random arrangement that is both flexible and can transmit light. Several different types of crystallins are fitted closely together like a beautifully even dry stone wall – except this one is perfectly clear. In the same way that gems in a bowl of water can look more glassy, the crystallin proteins take on a transparent appearance in the liquid contents of the cell.

The name crystallin is ironic, because if the proteins in the lens clumped together to form crystals, it would lose its transparency. One of the types of crystallins even acts as a ‘chaperone’, holding on to proteins that have become damaged and are therefore more likely to bunch together. Later in life, the broken proteins can become numerous enough to overwhelm their chaperones and aggregate together, forming cataracts.

Different forms of crystallin proteins. David S. Goodsell and the RCSB PDB- Molecule of the Month. (CC-BY-4.0 license)

Although the different types of crystallin proteins bear the same name, they have very different structures. These structures look very similar to other proteins elsewhere in the body, suggesting that they have been ‘recruited’ from other roles to become part of the lens.  So while crystallins are grouped under the same title because of their function as tough transparent proteins, in fact they appear to have very different origins. This is a great example of convergent evolution: different proteins following a variety of evolutionary paths to end up with the same function.

Often the crystallins look like the enzymes that help organisms handle different stresses (such as overheating) inside their bodies. In the process of being recruited as crystallins, they have changed and lost their original function. These changes have to be subtle, so they don’t destroy the structural qualities that make them so useful for forming a stable arrangement – one that lasts even when environmental conditions (sunlight, for example), are harsh.

B0002683 Developing eye in a chick embryo
Developing eye in a chick embryo. Inner red section will become the lens. by Kate Whitley. Wellcome Images. (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0)

With their separate origins and same destination, the crystallins are a great example of the phenomenon that Charles Darwin spotted more than 150 years ago. The Cambridge palaeobiologist Simon Conway Morris has been collecting stories of convergence for a number of years now, and believes they are a sign that evolution is more predictable than some people think. He also thinks that convergence is compatible with the existence of a creator. In other words, if there is a God who wanted to create, surely that creation could have happened through a long slow process? And if that long slow process contained a little predictability, hitting the same solutions to biological problems again and again, perhaps that is compatible with there being some sort of plan for the whole show?


Part 1: Imagination and Incredulity: The evolution of the eye

Charles Darwin, The Origin of Species

Crystallins, on the Protein Database education portal

Crystallins, on

Simon Conway Morris, The Runes of Evolution, and Life’s Solution

R Bancewicz 2015 mugshot small
© Faraday Institute

Ruth Bancewicz is a Senior Research Associate at The Faraday Institute for Science and Religion, where she works on the positive interaction between science and faith. After studying Genetics at Aberdeen University, she completed a PhD at Edinburgh University. She spent two years as a part-time postdoctoral researcher at the Wellcome Trust Centre for Cell Biology at Edinburgh University, while also working as the Development Officer for Christians in Science. Ruth arrived at The Faraday Institute in 2006, and is currently a trustee of Christians in Science.

Discipleship in all of life: Putting faith and science in the blender

Cropped from Morning Prayers by Don Christner. Flickr. (CC BY-ND 2.0)

How much does the natural world feature in the average Christian’s relationship with God? Church leaders often speak about ‘discipleship’, meaning the process of learning what it is to be a Christian and putting that knowledge into practice. The question is, are discipleship and our experience of the created order – trees, water, rocks and stars – held in separate watertight boxes, or are they blended Continue reading

What Animals Teach Christians about Getting Along

Portuguese Man o’ War By Volkan Yuksel (Own work) [CC BY-SA 3.0], via Wikimedia Commons

The deadly marine wonder, the Portuguese man o’ war, resembles a jellyfish with its beautiful blue and purple ship-shaped bladder and impressive 30-foot stinging tentacles. What may at first appear to be a single organism is actually a colony of four completely different types of polyp, working together so closely that they are not able to survive Continue reading

Imagination and Incredulity: The evolution of the eye


“To suppose that the eye…could have been formed by natural selection, seems, I freely confess, absurd in the highest possible degree. Yet…”

Charles Darwin, The Origin of Species

The ‘yet’, in Darwin’s introduction to ‘Organs of Extreme perfection and complication’ is very telling. The ideas that follow this oft-quoted sentence remind me a little of Paul’s letter to the Ephesians Continue reading

A Bucket of Frogs: Curiosity, Wonder, and the Theology of Science

Tadpole by Evan Murphy. Flickr. (CC BY-NC 2.0)

When I was three, I knocked a bucket of tadpoles all over on the patio. I remember the incident very clearly, so it must have been a relatively stressful one. It all happened Continue reading

Why We Need Disorder: A physicist’s perspective on the living world

Cropped from From Chaos to Order By Sebastien Wiertz. Flickr. (CC BY 2.0)

The Genesis creation story may seem to be all about God getting rid of disorder and turning it into order, but that’s not how a physicist sees it. In her lecture at the Christians in Science conference in Oxford a few weeks ago, Dr Rhoda Hawkins explained why.

Hawkins studies how unpredictable events on a microscopic scale can produce something very predictable and useful on a larger scale. For example Continue reading

Guest Post: When is a person?

baby-605588_1920At what point in human development can we recognise the presence of another person like us?  It’s an age-old question which cannot be avoided, and I’ve been interested in the recent discussion about this on this blog.  Each one of us comes to this question from a different perspective, so I would like to offer some reflections from the perspective of a baby doctor. As a neonatologist I have cared for many tiny and fragile babies, some as small as 22 weeks of gestation and weighing less than 500g. Continue reading