Life in a Bountiful Universe

Omega Centauri star cluster cropped
Omega centauri star cluster,, NASA

The astronomer Dr Jennifer Wiseman visited Cambridge recently to speak about her work on ‘exoplanet’ discovery. Exoplanets are planets in solar systems other than our own, and until 1989 they were the stuff of science fiction. Now we know there definitely are other planets in the universe, some of which may be like Earth. The discovery of life on other planets – perhaps single celled organisms – in the next few decades is a real possibility.

Our universe is active and fruitful. We live in an abundant universe, and can celebrate that with new knowledge. The changes made to the Hubble telescope in 2009 have brought us beautiful new pictures that show the universe in greater depth than ever before. This one of the Omega Centauri star cluster shows a startling variety of stars.

The universe is beautiful, and the range of telescopes that astronomers use are like a symphony orchestra, with many different instruments contributing to our knowledge of the universe. The Hubble telescope has a relatively narrow field of view, but can see deeper into space. The large ground-based telescopes can take wide-angle shots, and Infra Red or radio telescopes can detect differences in temperature.

The universe is vast and active, with old stars disintegrating and exploding into clouds of gas, and new stars forming as those clouds coalesce again. It takes several generations of stars to generate the chemical elements that are needed for life. When the right factors are all present, a star coalesces and dusty discs develop around it from which planets are born.

Galaxies such as the famous spiral galaxy contain around 100-200 billion stars, and there are at least 200 billion galaxies in the observable universe. Even if planets are rare, might there not be life elsewhere in this vast cosmos? There are now a thousand confirmed exoplanets, and research is still gathering pace. We might have as many as 5 billion planetary systems in our own galaxy. What scientists like Jennifer want to find out is, what fraction of the stars in our galaxy harbour potentially habitable planets? The easiest way to start is to look for planets similar to our own, because we already know Earth is hospitable to life. So we need Earth-sized planets with a crust, the right temperature for liquid water, and evidence of elements like oxygen and carbon in the atmosphere.

By the time of Jennifer’s talk about four Earth-like candidates had been found. The most promising one is too far away to do follow up study, but planets seem to be so common (perhaps one for every star in our galaxy) that it might not be long before we find one a bit nearer. Another was announced the week after the talk: one that showed evidence of water vapour in the atmosphere. This new planet is so hot that it’s unlikely to contain life, but it’s a start.

I am excited about the search for exoplanets, because if we find even very simple cells on another planet that would teach us a huge amount about how life developed. Does it always involve DNA? What might the precursors be? Are there alternative ways to generate life?

Jennifer Wiseman said that the human responses to the grandeur of the universe span a wide range. The data doesn’t tell you how to reflect on it, so your reaction depends on your perspective. As a Christian it leads her to worship, and I agree. I believe in a big God who is immensely creative and immensely generous. What we find in the universe helps me to understand a little more about him, and my awe turns to praise.

4 thoughts on “Life in a Bountiful Universe

  1. Baldscientist May 9, 2013 / 2:09 pm

    Wonderful indeed. As I middle-aged guy I feel privileged to have lived during the two proverbial periods, the first one when no planets out of our system were known and many people even doubted that they existed atvall to right now, a mere 20-something years later when we KNOW that they are out there, including some similar to our own planet.

    I co-teach a non-science majors astrobiology course, and it is so exciting because every single year we have to add material from the news because so many things are being discovered! It is my favorite course to teach (don’t tell my fellow pharmacologists/neurobiologists… (:-)…). Thanks do the post.


  2. Stephen Thompson May 9, 2013 / 11:05 pm

    Jennifer Wiseman said that the human responses to the grandeur of the universe span a wide range. The data doesn’t tell you how to reflect on it, so your reaction depends on your perspective.

    I think the second statement is insightful, and perhaps contradicts the preceding one, where ‘the grandeur of the universe’ is presented as a piece of data, whereas I think you are right to say that Jennifer has in fact chosen a mode of reflection. Is it deliberate that the word ‘grandeur’ is also found in Darwin’s line, “There is grandeur in this view of life…”

    “There is grandeur in this view of life, with its several powers, having been originally breathed into a few forms or into one; and that, whilst this planet has gone cycling on according to the fixed law of gravity, from so simple a beginning endless forms most beautiful and most wonderful have been, and are being, evolved.”

    It seems this ‘grandeur’ is a secondary response to the primary ‘view of life’, which is Darwin’s construct.

    In any case, I am bemused by the current enthusiasm for anticipating life ‘under the next atmosphere’ to be remotely probed by the world’s growingly accomplished astronomers. Especially among Christians it is reminiscent of the Victorian enthusiasm for speculating on the possibility of life on our near planetary neighbours. Although Conway Morris is a little ambiguous about his view at the conclusion of his book, ‘Life’s Solution: Inevitable Humans in a Lonely Universe’, I am much happier to settle for the opinion that even though evolutionary convergence may be ubiquitous here as a phenomenon, it is quite another thing to suggest that the whole process has been set off with anything like the frequency that would mean we would ever see evidence of it from here. Even just once, using telescopes, never mind on the moons of gas giants in our system.

    Is there a sense of ‘setting out a stall’ here? Is there a human calculation being made that says, we would rather have been seen discussing the existence of extraterrestrial life before its discovery, rather than holding our tongues and being skeptical? That it would look bad to be ‘proved wrong’ about ET and so bringing the faith position into ridicule yet again?

    I am much provoked by your final paragraph; I continue to wonder how we can appropriately navigate the category shifts between appreciation of great complexity, wonder, awe and then worship. Thank you for prompting further cogitation on this.


    • Ruth Bancewicz May 10, 2013 / 1:37 pm

      Thanks Stephen. No the link with Darwin was not intentional. And yes, grandeur is subjective – I guess I just assume that most people reading this will agree that the universe is grand in our current cultural climate! My enthusiasm for finding life on other planets research is purely biological – I am excited at the prospect (perhaps a couple of generations from now) of finding cells from somewhere else and analysing their biochemistry. Given the number of habitable planets being identified now I don’t think that’s the realm of scifi any more. Of course it may not happen, but there’s no harm looking. (So long as expensive space research is balanced off by sensible use of resources elsewhere!!!)


  3. michala June 11, 2013 / 2:17 am

    Gosh who knows whats out there in the vast quote arthur c.clarke I will be equally amazed if we discovered life elsewhere and if we never discovered life.elsewhere.the latter may be the most likely as intelligent life may be microbes not advanced civilizations as predicted by drakes cannot predict evolution and what life will look like on other earth like is cannot see the keplar system either.I believe wards rare earth theory is perhaps the most realistic view of why we have and never will contact alien advanced civilizations.think- if


Please leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s